
Scary Goats Theatre is a Melbourne-based troupe that has been slowly building momentum over the last four years. This week at The Motley Bauhaus, they opened their sixth season of A Twist of Fate, a horror anthology of sorts inspired by the likes of Black Mirror and The Twilight Zone.
Scary Goats Theatre is run by writer/producer/actor Chloe Towan, who writes and directs a play each Twist of Fate season, as well as hosting and performing in the show. Towan has a fascination with the supernatural, working as a guide on a ghost tour in her spare time.
Opening the first act for this special Halloween edition is Count On It, written by Towan & Liliana Braumberger. Count On It is a darkly comic, yet poignant dissection of PTSD and survivors’ guilt, fate and the futility of heroism and individualism, set during the Allied bombing campaign of Germany, primarily the civilian targets.
It centres on Maj. Roger Hart (Richard Mealey), a pilot who refused to bomb a city because of its connection to European culture, to Beethoven and the pilot’s view on divinity.
A trio of sirens, played by Kim Moore alongside Towan and Braumberger, are almost like the Fates of Greek mythology, the witches of Macbeth or even the Wraiths in Irish folklore. Death and misery seem to fuel their desires; they’re stalking Maj. Hart, seemingly longing to feast on his soul, which poses some extremely interesting questions that are just as poignant now as they were in wartime.
A good, twisted tale should never resolve too much, otherwise it doesn’t linger with you, like an old ghost story around a campfire. Deliciously, Towan and Braumberger leave the looming questions unresolved.
The black box staging works well to allow for supernatural and paranormal events to unfold. Braumberger’s soundscape is hauntingly mysterious: what are those numbers that are being broadcast over the airwaves? Why is the broadcast coming from the middle of nowhere?
With direction by Kate Weston, there is a real sense of paranoia in Count On It. It calls back to the ‘Foo Fighters’ of World War II, the US fighter pilots who first started documenting UFOs in the skies over Europe.

The Dollhouse, written by Jack Bengough, is the next play in the anthology, and has a quasi-Sherlock Holmes meets Hansel and Gretel meets Outlander with a Brothers Grimm-Pied Piper mash-up quality as well.
Simon Farley plays Robert, a 19th-century version of Castle, Remington Steele, with Lauren Sewell as the plucky young female warrior, Victoria, who is really the brains behind the operation. Robert and Victoria are searching for children who have gone missing in the woods, and they must make a Faustian deal to rescue them.
Hayley Michaels delivers a hilarious turn as the Old Lady, harking back to the Queen masquerading as the crone in Snow White. Michaels exudes campy Disney villainy and sex appeal, which leads our two heroes to make a very unorthodox and abstract choice.
With direction by Richard Mealey, the campiness of The Dollhouse is laid on very thick, almost to the point of overshadowing the dark fairy tale aspects. But there is a kind of sweet, oblivious love story bubbling under the surface that balances the campiness without becoming too cheesy.

Act Two begins with The Itch, written by Savier D’Arsie Marquez. The Itch is a masterclass in tight, witty, emotive and punchy writing, with Kafka-esque elements fused with body horror and gothic elements that reflect being cursed by your own desire to fit in.
Kate Weston’s direction alongside Marquez’ exciting writing showcases the contrast between the two central characters of Fi (Tayla Harry) and Joan (Chloe Towan). Joan’s tone and syntax show the struggle with trying not to conform despite the pressure of external forces. Joan’s voice has a masculine sharpness to her words, heightened by Harry’s delivery.
Towan’s Fi has a delicate cadence and a free-wheeling sense of creativity. There is a genuine chemistry between the pair as well that makes their struggle even more intense.
Joan’s transformation into the other gives The Itch the feel of a morality play, even something out of a Greek or Roman myth cycle. Fi’s own transformation from passive participant in life into an active, aggressive saboteur is a fairly reasonable reaction to what Joan has put her through.
Despite being tense and heartbreaking, the team have delivered a brilliant piece that has all the gravitas and humour of a full-length play.

The hardest part of any anthology or collection of literary or performance pieces is how you end. It doesn’t matter how great the beginning or middle or even how good the story is, the ending is everything. The creative team of A Twist of Fate knock it out of the park with one of the most extraordinary pieces I have seen for a very long time.
Soot by Emily Morey tells the story of three struggling actors, Bing (Kate Weston), Bang (Liliana Braumberger) and Bong (Ben Fox). Over the top and hilariously un-self-aware, they are struggling to find a direction, struggling to find anything that will save their theatrical careers.
All is lost until they find a strange little puppet, Soot (Richard Mealey). Chaos, manipulation and hilarity ensues as Soot seduces the three players into a hypnotic cultish neverland.
With direction, choreography, sound and puppet design by Towan, the last punch of the show doesn’t let up. The goofier, the campier and the darker the relationship between Soot and the trio becomes, the harder you’ll laugh and the sillier the story gets.
A Twist of Fate seems to be doing what so many other independent and even the larger well-known theatre companies are failing at. They’re showcasing up-and-coming writers, actors and creatives, attracting an audience and delivering extremely professionally produced productions.
This Halloween special of A Twist of Fate is perfect for those who want to support local theatre makers, and those who are craving a genuinely entertaining evening. Go out and get tickets before they run out. Or even pre-book for Scary Goats’ upcoming Christmas season, which, by all accounts, is usually their most unhinged spectacular.
A Twist of Fate Season 6 (66), Halloween Special is presented by Scary Goats Theatre. It runs to 31 October at The Motley Bauhaus. 118 Elgin Street, Carlton Vic 3053.
Tickets are available here.
Website: https://www.themotley.com.au/
Socials: https://www.instagram.com/scarygoatstheatre/
Photo credits: Kieran McNamara






Leave a Reply