Review: One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest Is Beautifully Brutal

•

The Scoop One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest Melbourne 2026 Jason Donovan

One flew east, and one flew west, and one flew over the cuckoo’s nest. 

The classic film, adapted from a classic play adapted from a classic novel, has landed back on Melbourne stages at the Athenaeum Theatre. It’s a story many know well, but this production sticks the landing of the same shocks and heartbreaks felt the first time you saw the story. 

In whatever form you may have seen Cuckoo’s Nest first, each bears its own individual mark. Here, Chief, played by Jeremy Proulx, christens the stage with an opening monologue akin to a prayer.

As the lighting shifts, a stark white hospital set is interrupted by the arrival of Jason Donovan as Randle P. McMurphy in a black leather jacket, a stark contrast to the soft of the white polyester patient uniforms.

With an unchanging set, this iteration shines through its performances. Each character is so uniquely complex, and every actor’s performance draws out something new from the source material.

Donovan is abrasive, yet not malicious in his portrayal of McMurphy, a man entirely out of control of his impulses. He plays a man who thinks he knows best; a man whose ego and strong will believe they can conquer anything. 

Jeremy Proulx as Chief is the palate cleanser of the story. His performance is measured, even in his character’s moments of panic. He drives the story with transitional monologues, eliciting genuine sympathy from the audience. He’s one of the characters who will grow outside the walls of the institution, one you can’t wait to see free from his prison of pain.

The Scoop One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest Melbourne 2026 Jason Donovan
Nadine Garner gives a stand out performance as Nurse Ratched Photo by Eugene Hyland

Nadine Garner is brilliant as Nurse Ratched. A role commonly misunderstood as the villain, she plays this harsh woman with poise, but you can see the cracks are forming.

Each sexist comment, each disrespect, each disregard for her authority, pushes her to her breaking point. She’s a woman grappling for control at a time when she does not have such a luxury.

On the surface, she represents the broken system, but deeper, she’s only part of it, using it as best she can for any sort of autonomy, a kind of forced respect. Garner’s strong presence and commanding voice weave these nuances together in a standout performance.

The full ensemble cast is equally strong. David James as Harding is who I ended up rooting for the most. He’s a man who needs this system, needs guidance, but not in this time. James plays him with his soul bared, a character unguarded in wanting to be ‘better’. 

Daniel R. Nixon as Billy Bibbit is tragic, and gives a delicate performance of a boy with a fragile, tormented mental state. 

I also loved John Xintavekonis as Martini, my favourite character from the film. Xintavekonis expertly balances the charm of Danny DeVito’s film portrayal of the same character, whilst still bringing new, endearing qualities that make the character his own.

The Scoop One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest Melbourne 2026 Jason Donovan
This is a beautifully brutal show and necessary viewing Photo by Eugene Hyland

Richard Roberts’ set design is chilling, empty and cold, a devastating glimpse into the militant nature of these facilities from this time. Ella Butler’s costuming is strong, creating textures and personality from a bleak, white palette.

Her costume for Nurse Ratched is my favourite, buttoned all the way up, skirt sitting at her ankles, and fitted in a strictly practical way. Yet she’s still sexualised in a vicious way by patients like McMurphy.

The lighting design by Niklas Pajanti plays with expressive cool and warm tones, pulsing a somehow soothing warning through the windows for Chief’s moments alone. 

The original music is slightly heavy handed at times; the end of some of the challenging scenes almost needed a beat of silence or a soft, potentially period-related tune to transition us from moment to moment.

Kohan Van SamBeek’s score is the strongest when it breaks the mould, like the piece at the end of Act One, a great, rebellious strike of guitar to cut through the tension and create a sense of triumph. 

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is a difficult, tragic story about mistreatment. It interrogates freedom, respect, authority and the broken systems society relies upon. It’s a beautifully brutal show with heart-wrenching performances that make it necessary viewing.

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest plays for a strictly limited season to 20 December at the Athenaeum Theatre, Melbourne. 

Tickets: https://www.ticketmaster.com.au/artist/885265

Website: https://cuckoosnest.com.au/

Socials: https://www.instagram.com/oneflewoverau/

Photo credits: Eugene Hyland

Follow The Scoop and join thousands of others on our socials for exclusive video content from media days, launches & opening nights!

Home • Theatre • Single item: Post

Share your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don’t miss a post, subscribe to our newsletter!

Where Australian Performing Arts Take Centre Stage

The Scoop circle logo png