★★★★☆

I didn’t get to see Woodward Productions’ Sherlock Holmes – The Mystery of the Valkyrie when it made its debut at QPAC back in 2023. After reading some of the reviews from that first season, though, I was incredibly intrigued to see what had changed and what had stayed the same for this new imagining, which now has Neil Gooding Productions on board as well.
For those who don’t know, The Mystery of the Valkyrie isn’t one of Doyle’s original stories. It’s a brand-new mystery written by Brisbane’s own Michael Futcher, which takes us back to 221B Baker Street and sees Holmes and Watson drawn into a grisly murder.
The clues are all there, as the marketing loves to remind you, but whether you’ll spot them in time is another thing entirely.
The core of the show has stayed the same. Same writer and director. Same leads: Bryan Probets as Professor Moriarty and Eugene Gilfedder as Sherlock Holmes. The Hogwarts-like moving staircases have stayed too, as have Craig Wilkinson’s projections.
And honestly, this core has kept the show grounded and relatable, and it’s what’s bringing audiences back to the Playhouse for a second time. Three years on, it’s clear the team knew exactly what was working.
What has changed is its length and some of its supporting cast and leads, with Ian Stenlake now taking on Dr Watson and Helen Howard stepping in as Irene Adler. This has led to a refreshed energy and a new vibe for the 2026 run.
This new variation is ten minutes shorter than its predecessor, which, according to some, was much needed, as the original length felt heavy. This reviewer, however, thinks it’s gone too far the other way.

The script was super-fast-paced and could be a little hard to follow at times. Characters came and went quickly, and fight scenes broke out without me really understanding why, or who was on whose side.
If you’ve got a previous knowledge of Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes lore, you’re probably fine, but I fear for newcomers to his works, this may be a confusing ride. Even my guest and I, who have both seen the series and the movies before, were a little lost at times.
There were a couple of moments where we were still trying to work out who someone was, and the show had already moved on to the next scene. I’d have been more than happy to sit through those extra ten minutes if it meant the story got a bit more time to settle in between all the twists.
Now, for the real pacesetter, though. The set, while simple, is awesome. Isabel Hudson’s moving staircases, much like the ones in Hogwarts Castle from Harry Potter, whip around the stage to set scenes and move us through the streets of London as Watson and Holmes fought off attackers.
The moving set pieces are a true showstopper, and it’s amazing how much a handful of staircases can do when they’re used this well.
The lighting, which I wish I could credit, is also a real highlight. The illumination of certain elements of the stage as Holmes and Watson weave their way through the mystery of the Valkyrie is paramount, and on a set this simple, it is the lighting that tells you exactly where to look.
Similarly, the projection work by Craig Wilkinson is just as brilliant as I had hoped after reading about it. The creation of the Reichenbach Falls for the climax of the story is astounding, and the mathematical projections to help us work through Sherlock’s mind palace are a really nice touch.
With a script moving this quickly, those little visual clues are a big help in keeping up with what is going on inside Holmes’ head.

Gilfedder is an incredible Holmes, reprising the role three years after his last outing as the Baker Street detective. No one will ever live up to RDJ or Benedict, but Gilfedder comes a pretty close third, and that’s saying something, because they’re some pretty big shoes to fill.
Probets is similarly fantastic in his reprised role of Professor Moriarty. Unfathomably smart, cunning, and all kinds of evil. Probets controls the twisted and brilliant mind of the professor with ease, and you never once doubt that this is a man capable of outsmarting Holmes.
Ian Stenlake as Dr Watson is great. He is controlled, constantly in his own head, and you could see his inner clocks working away trying to keep up with Holmes. Taking over such a well-known role in a returning show can’t be easy, but Stenlake makes it his own.
Helen Howard as Irene Adler is a quiet assassin. She didn’t need to be loud to leave her mark. The remainder of the cast, including Helen Cassidy as Mrs Hudson and Cameron Hurry as Mycroft, along with Danny Brown, Stephen Hirst, Rowan Chapman and NJ Price, are also brilliant and round out the show nicely.
All in all, Sherlock Holmes – The Mystery of the Valkyrie is a pleasant first watch, and while the story could be a little hard to follow at times, the superb cast, incredible set, and impressive staging and projections more than make up for it.
If you’re already a Holmes fan, this one’s an easy pick. If you’re new to Baker Street, maybe do a little reading before you head in, and you’ll get a whole lot more out of it. It’s also really nice to see a homegrown Brisbane work come back for a second season at QPAC, and with a cast this strong, I’d love to see it head further afield.
Sherlock Holmes – The Mystery of the Valkyrie is presented by Woodward Productions and Neil Gooding Productions and runs to 29 November 2026 at the Playhouse, QPAC.
Tickets are available here.
Website: https://www.qpac.com.au/whats-on/2026/sherlock-holmes-the-mystery-of-the-valkyrie
Socials: https://www.instagram.com/woodward_productions/ and https://www.instagram.com/atqpac/
Images supplied.






Leave a Reply