
Hayes Theatre Co presents Silver Tongue in a world premiere production. The birth of a new Australian musical is always cause to crack a bottle across the bow.
We should never underestimate the time, energy and sheer labour required to bring an original work to the stage. Hayes Theatre Co deserves recognition for its continued commitment to developing and presenting new musical theatre.
Creating space for homegrown stories, letting artists take creative risks and putting new musicals in front of an audience is how a vibrant musical theatre culture is built.
A first production is rarely the end of the road. It is a waypoint: an opportunity to discover what works, what needs further attention and where a work might travel next. Silver Tongue, drawing on Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, is very much part of that ongoing journey.
The musical follows young Jim and the charismatic pirate Silver Tongue through shifting allegiances, romantic entanglements and competing ambitions. There is rich material to mine in Stevenson’s world, and the promise of a queer reimagining offers an intriguing way into the familiar story. But the production never quite finds its bearings.
What begins with the suggestion of a distinctive queer perspective settles into a conventional romantic comedy, with several love stories jostling for attention. There is nothing wrong with a rom-com, but the result feels less adventurous than the premise suggests.
A queer reimagining is about more than who is on stage, though; it is a perspective that can reshape how we see the world and the relationships within it. That more interesting possibility feels like waters still to be charted.

The book is the work of Jacob Parker, who has been amassing strong theatre credits and makes his first foray into musical theatre here, in partnership with Miranda Middleton, who is carving out a niche of her own in the form. Together they are certainly not short of ideas.
There are jokes aplenty: musical theatre in-jokes, broad comedy, wordplay and moments that veer towards Gilbert and Sullivan. The inventiveness is evident, but the tone is not always consistent. Some gags land beautifully; others interrupt the flow, leaving the audience waiting for the story to get back under way.
Richard Carroll’s brisk direction keeps the action moving, even if not every punchline finds its mark. At times, the show feels like a ship with too many hands on the wheel.
The musical score by Alec Steedman is, without doubt, the production’s soul and its musical anchor. Eclectic and frequently toe-tapping, it moves with ease between soaring ballads, bawdy sea shanties and a variety of musical theatre styles. Land Hoe! is an immediate earworm and surely has a life beyond the show.
Steedman, who also performs on violin, brings palpable focus, artistry and musicianship to the production. There is a sense of someone deeply invested in the music as an art form.
The score delivers the evening’s most memorable moments, leaving one wishing the storytelling gave it more room to shine.
Billie Palin is a magnetic Silver Tongue. With formidable vocal assurance, comic timing, energy and stage presence, she brings versatility to the role and commands the stage.

Natalie Abbott brings real warmth to Dick, Tana Laga’aia is assured as Hands, and Jack Green is a delight as Squire. Shannen Alyce Quan is worth the price of admission as Livesey, while Marty Alix brings an engaging openness to young Jim. The ensemble clearly relishes the material.
The production is well served by its creative team. Hailley Hunt’s set gives us a literal slice of a ship, complete with steering wheel, rigging and movable boxes, creating a warm timber world that makes versatile use of the space.
Sam Hernandez’s costumes are pared-back and playful, with just enough detail to conjure the olde world. Chiara Assetta’s choreography is fresh and fun, and Victoria Falconer provides the musical direction while also appearing onstage as Peg the parrot.
Silver Tongue has its pleasures: a lively and eclectic score, an inventive production and a committed ensemble. There is genuine treasure here, particularly in Steedman’s music, even if the story doesn’t yet chart a convincing course and its more distinctive queer proposition is still waiting to be explored.
But perhaps that is also the point of a first production. A new musical needs somewhere to begin, an audience to test it against and the opportunity to discover what it might yet become. Hayes Theatre Co continues to provide that essential platform.
The voyage may not be complete, but the ship has left port and that matters for getting new Australian musicals out into the world.
Silver Tongue runs to 12 December at Hayes Theatre. 19 Greenknowe Avenue Potts Point NSW 2011.
Tickets are available here.
Website: https://hayestheatre.com.au/event/silver-tongue/
Socials: https://www.instagram.com/hayestheatreco_official/
Photo credits: John McRae






Leave a Reply